Blog Content
12
Jan
2026
Homeowners insurance and pitbulls can be a tricky combination for Massachusetts families. Many pit bull owners find that their beloved family dog affects their ability to get coverage - or significantly increases their premiums.
Quick Answer: Can You Get Homeowners Insurance with a Pit Bull?
The numbers tell the story. Dog bite liability claims cost homeowners $1.116 billion in 2023, with the average claim exceeding $32,000. These statistics drive insurers to create "dangerous dog" lists that typically include pit bulls alongside Rottweilers, German Shepherds, and Dobermans.
Yet here's what many don't know: Pit bulls pass temperament tests 87.4% of the time - actually outperforming Golden Retrievers. This disconnect between perception and reality creates real challenges for responsible pit bull owners in Newton, Wellesley, Brookline, and throughout Massachusetts.
Whether you're a current pit bull owner facing coverage issues or considering adoption, understanding your insurance options is crucial. The good news? Solutions exist for determined pet parents willing to do their homework.
If you're a pit bull parent in Massachusetts, you've probably finded that finding homeowners insurance and pitbulls coverage isn't as straightforward as you'd hoped. The truth is, insurance companies view the world through a lens of statistics and potential payouts - and unfortunately, certain breeds get caught in this numbers game.
Let me walk you through what's really happening behind the scenes and, more importantly, how you can steer these waters successfully.
Here's the reality: insurance companies maintain what they call "restricted breed lists," and pit bulls almost always make the cut. You'll typically see these breeds flagged as higher risk: pit bull-type dogs (including American Pit Bull Terriers and American Staffordshire Terriers), Rottweilers, German Shepherds, Doberman Pinschers, and several others like Chow Chows, Akitas, and Cane Corsos.
Why do they do this? The numbers are pretty staggering. Dog bite liability claims cost homeowners $1.116 billion in 2023 alone. The average claim now exceeds $32,000, and that figure has jumped 82.5% since 2014. From an insurer's perspective, they're looking at financial risk and bite severity potential.
Now, I know what you're thinking - and you're absolutely right to be frustrated. These breed restrictions often ignore individual dog behavior and responsible ownership. But understanding the insurer's mindset helps you approach the situation strategically.
Here's what owning a pit bull might mean for your coverage: You could face increased premiums, specific breed exclusions in your policy, or even denied coverage altogether. Some insurers might require additional umbrella coverage before they'll work with you.
Let me be crystal clear about something crucial: never hide your dog's breed from your insurer. The consequences of non-disclosure can be devastating. If an incident occurs and your insurance company finds you withheld information about your pit bull, they can deny your claim, cancel your entire policy, or leave you personally liable for tens of thousands in damages. For context on how premiums work in our state, check out our guide on Average Homeowners Insurance Mass.
The good news? Some insurers take a more progressive approach, focusing on individual dog behavior rather than blanket breed restrictions. These breed-neutral insurers evaluate dogs based on their actual history and behavior, not just their DNA.
But here's something important for us here in Massachusetts: unlike New York, Michigan, and Pennsylvania, our state doesn't have laws prohibiting breed discrimination by insurance companies. This means insurers operating in Newton, Wellesley, Brookline, Needham, Belmont, and Natick can legally maintain breed-specific restrictions.
In January 2022, New York banned homeowners insurance breed discrimination entirely. While Massachusetts regulations haven't followed suit yet, you can still find coverage by asking the right questions.
When speaking with potential insurers, be upfront: "Do you have breed restrictions for liability coverage? Are pit bulls included? Do you consider individual dog behavior?" This direct approach saves everyone time and helps you find the right fit faster.
This is exactly where working with a knowledgeable local broker makes all the difference. We understand the Massachusetts insurance landscape inside and out, and we know which carriers are more flexible with pit bull coverage. If you're searching for Home Insurance Companies Near Me Mass, we can connect you with the right options for your specific situation.
Here's where you can really make a difference in your insurance search. Smart pit bull owners know that demonstrating responsible ownership and a well-behaved dog can significantly improve their coverage options.
The gold standard is earning an American Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen (CGC) certificate. This American Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen (CGC) program puts your dog through a 10-step test that proves good manners and obedience. Many insurers view this certificate very favorably.
Temperament tests are another powerful tool. Remember those ATTS statistics I mentioned earlier? Pit bulls pass at 87.4% - higher than many "family-friendly" breeds. If your dog has passed such a test, that documentation can be incredibly valuable.
Other steps that can help include spaying/neutering your dog (often associated with calmer temperaments), maintaining up-to-date vet records, and most importantly, maintaining a clean bite history. Obedience training certificates, socialization records, and documentation of responsible ownership practices all paint a picture of a well-managed, low-risk pet.
Keep meticulous records of everything. When it comes to homeowners insurance and pitbulls, documentation can be the difference between coverage and rejection.
Sometimes, even with the best preparation, standard homeowners insurance isn't an option. Don't panic - several alternatives can provide the protection you need.
Canine liability insurance is a stand-alone policy designed specifically for dog-related incidents. Unlike your homeowners policy, this focuses solely on third-party damages your dog might cause. It covers medical bills, property damage, and legal defense fees, but won't cover damage to your own property or injuries to your household members.
Personal umbrella insurance is another excellent option. This higher liability limits coverage kicks in when your primary policy limits are exhausted. If your homeowners policy covers $300,000 in liability but a serious incident results in $800,000 in damages, an umbrella policy covers that difference. We offer comprehensive Personal Umbrella Insurance Massachusetts coverage that can provide this crucial extra layer of protection.
These stand-alone policies can be particularly valuable when your homeowners policy has policy exclusions for certain breeds. Without proper coverage, you're personally responsible for all costs - and a single incident can easily exceed $35,000 in medical and legal expenses.
The key is finding the right combination of coverage that protects both your family and your four-legged family member. That's where our expertise in the Massachusetts market really pays off for our clients throughout the Greater Boston area.
Finding the right homeowners insurance and pitbulls coverage in Massachusetts doesn't have to feel overwhelming. Throughout this guide, we've explored the reality that while many insurers view pit bulls as higher risk due to bite claim statistics, responsible ownership and the right approach can open doors to quality coverage.
The insurance landscape is shifting. More companies are recognizing that a dog's individual behavior matters more than breed stereotypes. When pit bulls pass temperament tests at an 87.4% rate - outperforming many "family-friendly" breeds - it's clear that blanket breed restrictions don't tell the whole story.
Your path forward starts with honesty and preparation. Always disclose your pit bull to insurers upfront. Hiding your dog's breed might seem tempting, but it's a guaranteed way to have claims denied and policies canceled when you need them most. Instead, arm yourself with documentation that showcases your dog's good behavior.
Training certificates make a real difference. That Canine Good Citizen certificate isn't just a nice-to-have - it's powerful evidence that your pit bull is well-behaved and properly socialized. Keep those vet records current, maintain that clean bite history, and document everything. These steps transform you from "just another pit bull owner" into a responsible pet parent who deserves quality coverage.
Remember your options extend beyond traditional policies. If standard homeowners insurance proves challenging in Newton, Wellesley, or anywhere across the Greater Boston area, canine liability insurance and umbrella policies provide crucial protection. These alternatives ensure you're never left financially vulnerable, even when primary coverage falls short.
At Kovalev Insurance, we've helped countless Massachusetts families steer these exact challenges. We understand that your pit bull isn't just a pet - they're family. That's why we take the time to find personalized solutions that protect both your home and your four-legged family member.
Here's your action plan: Start by gathering your dog's training certificates, vet records, and behavioral documentation. Then reach out to breed-neutral insurers, asking specific questions about their policies. If you hit roadblocks, don't give up - explore those alternative coverage options we discussed.
Most importantly, don't go it alone. Our team at Kovalev Insurance specializes in finding solutions for complex insurance situations across Brookline, Needham, Belmont, Natick, and beyond. We leverage our industry connections and expertise to secure the coverage you need at rates you can afford.
Your pit bull brings joy, loyalty, and love to your family. Don't let insurance worries diminish that bond. Take these proactive steps, and let us help you find the peace of mind you deserve. Contact us today to discuss your options for the Best Homeowners Insurance Massachusetts - we're confident we can find the right solution for your unique situation.
X